What
Where

Get email updates when new matches pop up.

Sidney Spencer, 59

sweat-lodge-8am-101309

Owners of the Angel Valley Retreat Center, Amayra and Michael HamiltonOwners of the Angel Valley Retreat Center, Amayra and Michael Hamilton

 

---

sweat-lodge-12pm-101609

sweatlodge10p101709

sweatlodge10p102109

sweatlodge10p102109

Large Map

2nd Lawsuit Announced in Sweat Lodge Tragedy

Survivor's attorney: Ray coerced them to stay

Updated: Monday, 26 Oct 2009, 10:02 AM EDT
Published : Sunday, 25 Oct 2009, 7:44 PM EDT

A 59-year-old southern Arizona woman who survived two hours in a deadly Sedona sweat lodge on Oct. 8 is suing self-help guru James Arthur Ray. Her attorney is calling the sweat lodge a "death trap."

Sidney Spencer said she paid $9,000 to attend the 5-day "Spiritual Warrior" retreat. Spencer was one of 21 people who fell ill while sitting in a 120-degree makeshift sweat lodge that was supposed to cleanse the body and take people to another spiritual level. Three people died.

Spencer, of Patagonia, Ariz., says James Arthur Ray coerced and intimidated people to stay inside the tent -- to conquer their discomfort. That was despite reports that people were screaming for water, vomiting and passing out.

Spencer was taken by helicopter to Flagstaff Medical Center -- and she says she nearly died from kidney and liver failure.

"When she came to, she was spitting up blood, she had double vision, she was in intensive care for four and a half days," says Spencer's attorney, Ted Schmidt.

"There were numerous times when people attempted to leave. He did not physically restrain them, but he told the group, 'You stick it out, you have to stick it out, break through your barrier,'" says Schmidt.

In an interview with AP earlier this week, a 43-year-old survivor from Texas, Beverly Bunn, says that Ray was dismissive of participants' cries for help. Bunn recalls hearing someone cry from within the tent, "I can't get her to move, I can't get her to wake up!" to which Ray apparently responded, "Leave her alone, she'll be dealt with in the next round."

Bunn says the 5-day retreat began with days of physically-demanding exercises and stringent fasting, all culminating in the sweat lodge ceremony.

The other victims

49-year-old Lizabeth Neuman, of Prior Lake, Minn., spent a week in a coma with organ damage before passing away on Oct. 17. Two others, 38-year-old Kirby Brown of Westtown, N.Y. and 40-year-old James Shore of Milwaukee died in the tent.

Neuman's family is also planning a lawsuit. Flagstaff attorney Louis Diesel said that it's clear appropriate measures were not taken to prevent Neuman's death. Diesel said Neuman was healthy, athletic and didn't have any underlying medical problems.

The Yavapai County Sheriff's Office is investigating the deaths as homicide. James Arthur Ray is being called a person of interest. He's calling the deaths a horrible tragedy and says he's put together his own team of investigators to determine what went wrong.

  • Marketplace
Advertisement
  • Suggested Search
  • Similar Stories